Insights on “South Dakota v. Wayfair” SCOTUS Decision

Guidance and insights to help remote sellers affected by sales tax compliance changes.

Kent Johnson

Kent Johnson

Partner in Charge, Indirect Tax practice, KPMG (US)

+1 206-913-4112
View more

The Effects of Wayfair

On June 21, 2018, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in favor of the state in South Dakota v. Wayfair, a case in which South Dakota sought to have a statute imposing economic nexus standards on remote sellers upheld by the Court. In its decision, the Court concluded that the physical presence standard that had existed for decades for sales and use tax nexus was “unsound and incorrect.” The Court overruled its prior decisions in National Bellas Hess and Quill, thus opening the door for states to require remote sellers to collect and remit sales and use taxes.

Now that Quill has been overturned, what is next for sellers? The Court did not ultimately opine on the constitutionality of South Dakota’s law, but remanded the case for the state court to determine whether there were any other Commerce Clause concerns with South Dakota’s economic nexus law. However, the Court noted that the law contained several provisions that appeared to ensure that the law would pass constitutional muster and would not create undue burdens on sellers.

And while the litigation is not yet over in South Dakota, over a dozen states have already acted and have laws or regulations on their books similar to South Dakota’s law. The effective dates of these provisions vary by state. Certain states are currently prohibited from enforcing their economic nexus laws or have provisions stating that that the laws can be enforced prospectively only. As these provisions become effective and enforceable, which many will in the weeks and months to come, sellers will need to respond accordingly.

Checklist of next steps:

Step 1 – Review nexus footprint

Step 2 – Consider the overall business implications

Step 3 – Make taxability determinations

Step 4 – Review and consider technology needs

Step 5 – Filing compliance and initial registration

The Wayfair Supreme Court Decision: Navigating a World Without Quill

In the wake of the U.S. Supreme Court's landmark decision in South Dakota v. Wayfair, companies will need to act quickly to avoid unnecessary exposure. Companies will now need to determine when and how they must come into compliance with existing economic nexus standards.

Related service

Six Steps Remote Sellers Can Take to Prepare for the Wayfair Decision

 

In this CFO magazine article, Kent Johnson and Harley Duncan outline how the U.S. Supreme Court's reversal of Quill may impact remote sellers, particularly those selling into the U.S. from foreign countries.

 

Read more